The Calhoun Institute Repairing The Irreparable: Revisiting The Federalism Decisions Of The Burger Court | The Calhoun Institute

Repairing the Irreparable: Revisiting the Federalism Decisions of the Burger Court

federalism

Repairing the Irreparable: Revisiting the Federalism Decisions of the Burger Court

David Scott Louk, University of California, Berkeley, School of Law, Students , April 20, 2015, Yale Law Journal, Vol. 125, p. 682, 2016

Abstract: The text of a Supreme Court opinion rarely tells the full story of the debates, discussions, and disagreements that resulted in a particular decision. Drawing on previously unexamined archival papers of the Justices of the Burger Court, this Note tells the story of the Burger Court’s federalism jurisprudence between 1975 and 1985, famously bookended by a pair of rare and abrupt reversals of Supreme Court precedent. The Note documents the Justices’ deliberations for the first time, sheds new light on the institutional workings of the Court, and enriches our understanding of the foundations of modern federalism. In its federalism cases, the Burger Court grappled with the challenge of balancing the states’ autonomy against the rise of new national problems and an expanding federal government’s solutions to them. The Justices’ papers show that they were more attuned to policy outcomes and the real-world consequences of their decisions than may typically be assumed. Above all, the papers reveal the Burger Court’s deep struggle to articulate a sustainable federalism jurisprudence given the constraints of judicial craft. As the Note concludes, however, the Burger Court’s uneven federalism experiments nonetheless laid the groundwork for the Court’s subsequent attempts to fashion more workable doctrines. The Rehnquist and Roberts Courts have adjudicated federalism disputes more effectively by avoiding impracticable doctrines and remaining mindful of the institutional limitations of courts as federalism referees.

Number of Pages in PDF File: 47

About the Author

Barry Clark
I am a Southerner, a father, husband and Christian and a soon to be retired field grade officer on active duty in the Army; I have served for just over thirty years. I spent four years of my youth at The Citadel in Charleston . I am neither a theologian nor a professional historian. I do however ask many questions and endeavor to find answers and I believe, or at least hope, that I think critically and with the understanding that God provides. http://www.calhouninstitute.com/about-barry-clark/

Be the first to comment on "Repairing the Irreparable: Revisiting the Federalism Decisions of the Burger Court"

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.


*